The Lunch Lady

Mexican hot chocolate cookies

Soft chocolate cookies with cinnamon, chocolate chips and an optional toasted marshmallow. A powdered sugar, cinnamon and ancho dusting makes an easy finish at home.

Jump to recipe

Published

Servings
About 30 cookies
Total time
About 1 hour

Includes a short cool. Add 20 minutes if the dough needs chilling. Use about 45 grams of dough per cookie.

A kitchen torch browning a marshmallow half on a large chocolate cookie, with more marshmallow-topped cookies behind it.
Tuesday, October 20: Mexican hot chocolate cookies with halved marshmallows, toasted to finish.

Hot chocolate, this time as a cookie

We made Mexican hot chocolate cakes earlier in the year. Tuesday, we took that same chocolate-and-cinnamon idea and made cookies. I think the kids liked these even more than the cakes.

At school, I cut big marshmallows in half, pressed one onto each warm cookie and torched the tops. The toasted marshmallow against that soft chocolate cookie is really good.

At home, I would happily skip the torch. A little powdered sugar mixed with cinnamon and ancho chile over the top sounds absolutely killer. That finish is an option here, so you can make the cookies without buying a torch or even opening a bag of marshmallows.

Why I use Sunrise flour

Sunrise Flour Mill graciously donates flour to our kitchen. Their Heritage White is organic, unbleached and grown without glyphosate, according to their farming and testing information. Choosing organic food can reduce exposure to some pesticide residues, which is one reason I pay attention to it when cooking for kids. The American Academy of Pediatrics supports limiting unnecessary pesticide exposure. That is a sourcing benefit, not a promise that one flour makes a cookie healthier. Regular all-purpose flour also works in this recipe.

What grass-fed butter brings

I used grass-fed butter in these. Pasture feeding changes the butter's fat composition, and research comparing feeding systems found higher levels of beta-carotene and conjugated linoleic acid in pasture-derived butter. Beta-carotene is a compound the body can use to make vitamin A. Those differences are real, but that study did not test health benefits in children eating the butter. It is still a food rich in saturated fat. I like choosing good ingredients for a treat, and this is very much a treat.

Home recipe

Mexican hot chocolate cookies

The Lunch Lady · Jared Veldheer

Servings
About 30 cookies
Prep time
About 25 minutes
Cook time
About 25 to 30 minutes in two oven rounds; 11 to 13 minutes per sheet
Total time
About 1 hour

Includes a short cool. Add 20 minutes if the dough needs chilling. Use about 45 grams of dough per cookie.

Equipment: Kitchen scale, mixer or hand mixer, mixing bowls, two baking sheets, parchment, cookie scoop, cooling rack

Ingredients

Check off ingredients as you go.

Cookie dough

Optional marshmallow finish

Optional no-torch dusting

Instructions

Mix the dough

  1. Heat a conventional oven to 350°F. Line two baking sheets with parchment. Whisk the flour, sifted cocoa, cinnamon, baking soda, baking powder and salt together.
  2. Beat the softened butter with both sugars for 2 to 3 minutes until creamy and a little lighter. Scrape the bowl. Beat in the eggs and vanilla until smooth.
  3. Add the dry ingredients in three additions on low speed, mixing only until no dry flour remains. Scrape the bottom of the bowl. Fold in the chocolate chips with a spatula.
  4. Scoop about 45 grams of dough per cookie, roughly a generous 2 tablespoons. Leave about 4 inches between the centers, up to 12 cookies on a standard half-sheet pan. If the dough is very soft or the first cookies spread too far, chill it for about 20 minutes before scooping the rest.

Bake and finish

  1. Bake for about 11 to 13 minutes, checking at 10. If baking two sheets at once, swap their rack positions halfway through. The edges should be set while the centers still look a little soft. Keep remaining dough cool while the first sheets bake.
  2. For the marshmallow version, immediately press a half marshmallow, cut side down, onto each hot cookie. Let the cookies sit on the pan for 5 minutes, then move to a rack. A soft, untoasted marshmallow is a perfectly good finish.
  3. To toast the marshmallows with a kitchen torch, first transfer the cookies to a bare metal pan. Keep parchment and other flammable materials away, then move the flame across the marshmallow tops until golden.
  4. For the no-torch version, leave off the marshmallows and cool the cookies. Mix the powdered sugar, cinnamon and a small pinch of ancho. Taste the mixture, add more ancho only if you want it, and sift lightly over the tops.

Recipe notes

  • Use the gram weights if you have a scale. Cocoa and flour measurements change a lot depending on how tightly a cup is filled.
  • Dutch-process cocoa is the cocoa in the school recipe. Natural cocoa changes the flavor and how the leavening behaves.
  • The dough has cinnamon, not chile. The ancho belongs to the optional home dusting and can be left out.
  • Sunrise flour contains wheat and gluten. Heritage wheat is not a gluten-free substitute.
  • You can make smaller cookies, but start checking earlier. The 11- to 13-minute estimate is for the larger 45-gram scoops.